I am really happy that I did not read others' reviews for this book before I picked it up, as I might have skipped it altogether and missed out on one of my new favorite YA series. (Many were actually saying not to read it simply because of the American version's cover depicting a teenage Sherlock Holmes looking a bit too much like widely mocked Canadian pop singer Justin Beiber. Luckily the copy I first found was the British cover!)
I had just finished reading all of the original 4 novels and 56 short stories by Doyle and was positively going through some kind of fictional character detox needing my next hit of the witty British detective when I stumbled across this little gem of a book. I had my doubts at first, but thought, "What the heck, I've wasted $3 on worse things", and so I gingerly tossed it onto the counter at Edward McKay with my other selections.
With the task of reading through the tall stack of books I bought that day, several weeks went past before it was time to start Death Cloud, but once I did...it was love at first page! I was hooked from the first chapter until the last!
Basically, this is the story of young Sherlock Holmes, age 14, before he became the arrogant super brain that we all know him as today.
The book starts with the teen being collected by his brother, the enigmatic character of Mycroft Holmes, and being delivered to stay the Summer with his previously estranged aunt and uncle. Naturally, there is a mysterious dead body involved with the cause of death not immediately obvious. Would it really be Sherlock Holmes if it were just a cut and dry homicide in the first place?
We meet several new characters, most memorable being the American "Wild Bill/Mark Twain" tutor named Amyus Crowe and his headstrong, wild at heart daughter Virginia. But as for the most lovable and least lovable new characters? Those awards would go, respectively, to street smart orphan Matty (reminds me a bit of the character of Dodger from Oliver Twist) and the evil and cold hearted Housekeeper of the Holmes estate.
The book continues on the tell the story of young Sherlock being taught by Mr. Crowe on how to observe and analyze as he finds himself drawn into several mysterious deaths and a much larger conspiracy involving a revenge plot of a unique and grotesque villain. Things do not always go smoothly for him and he does not always have the right answers just in the nick of time. That is part of the magic of reality that makes this series a little better than some other Holmes fictions I have read since then. He has to learn, and often it is learning the hard way with unexpected and scary consequences. The character grows and changes through all of these experiences and that pleased me greatly!
I felt the writing of the book flowed well and the pace kept up an even keel. It was absolutely stuffed full of action scenes and plenty of moments for young Sherlock to learn to think and analyze and develop into the master of observation that we all love! It was a real treat of this book to watch him grow into his character.
The bad guys were villainous on an epic scale as would be expected...no, demanded!...of any book claiming Sherlock Holmes as the main protagonist.
The main antagonist is, just to be suitably vague without spoilers, positively a magnificent work of art!
I will bring up the fact that part of the engaging action scenes of this book involve torture and several gruesome deaths. I cannot recommend this book for all children, though it is a YA genre.
But, I gave it to my 9 year old and he LOVED it! He finished the book, set it down, and immediately picked up and began reading book two. However I would like to point out that he is very familiar with the idea that authors must write such scenes that might be shocking and that they are nothing more than works of fiction from a person's imagination.
Not all children can separate reality and fiction like that, so please be careful if you choose to give this one to a kid younger than the recommended age of teen and older.
That stated, let me also say that Alex did love the story as much as I did and every chapter he would update me on what was happening just to see if he could finagle a spoiler or two from me of whether or not Sherlock was going to escape a burning barn or whether we figure out who that weird housekeeper really is.
Both he and I give this book a huge thumbs up and he actually just gave it to his best friend to read.
Dear Mr. Lane, for writing such a fun and gripping story with such loveable and relatable characters, we forgive you for letting them put Justin Beiber on the cover.